July 13th, 2011
the difference between liberalism and radicalism…
i am finishing up the vegetarian myth and really want to share some excellent passages like this one…
So here’s the basic education in revolution that you didn’t get in public school. There are two cardinal differences between liberal- ism and radicalism. The first can be characterized as idealism versus materialism. Liberalism is idealist. The crucible of social reality is the realm of ideas, in concepts, language, attitudes. In contrast, radical- ism is materialist. Radicals see society as composed of actual institu- tions—economic, political, cultural—which wield power, including the power to use violence.
The second disagreement is on the primary social unit. Liberal- ism is individualist, locating the basic organization of society in the individual. Hence, liberal strategies for political change are almost exclusively individual actions. For radicals, the basic social unit is a class or group, whether that’s racial class, sex caste, economic class, or other grouping. Radicalism of whatever stripe understands oppression as group-based harm. For liberals, defining people as members of a group is the harm. In contrast, radicals believe that identifying your interests with others who are dispossessed—and developing loyalty to your people—is the first, crucial step in building a liberation move- ment.
Liberals essentially think that oppression is a mistake, a misun- derstanding, and changing people’s minds is the way to change the world. Hence, liberals place a tremendous emphasis on education as a political strategy. Radicals understand oppression as a set of interlock- ing institutions, and, one way or another, the strategy for liberation involves direct confrontation with power to take those institutions apart.
The Left in this country has embraced liberalism to the point of becoming completely unhitched from any notion of actually being effective. Activism has turned into one big group therapy session. It doesn’t matter what we accomplish—what matters is how we feel
about it. The goal of any action isn’t to change the material balance of power, it’s to feel “empowered” or to feel “community” or to feel our hearts open to our inner children because our mean, mean mothers never loved us, and all of it is endless and self-referential and useless. And the people who get caught up in this workshop culture will insist that their precious little navels have something to do with changing the world. Meanwhile, the planet is being eviscerated. If you want to do this with your life, well, it’s your life, but please don’t pretend that you’re changing the world.
The related dead end of individualism is the extreme personal purity of the “lifestyle activists.” Understand: the task of an activist is not to negotiate systems of power with as much personal integrity as possible—it’s to dismantle those systems. Neither of these approach- es—personal psychological change or personal lifestyle choices—is going to disrupt the global arrangements of power. They’re both ultimately liberal approaches to injustice, rerouting the goal from po- litical change to personal change. This is easier, much easier, because it makes no demands on us. It requires no courage or sacrifice, no persistence or honor, which is what direct confrontations with power must require. But personal purity only asks for shopping and smug- ness. The mainstream version involves hybrid cars, soy milk, soy burg- ers, and soy babies, and checking off the “green power” option on your electric bill. On the very fringe, there is a more extreme version which offers a semi-nomadic life of essentially mooching off the em- ployed. To point out the obvious: power doesn’t care. Power doesn’t notice the existence of anarchist freegans and it certainly doesn’t care if they eat out of dumpsters. Power will only care when you build a strategic movement against it. Individual action will never be effec- tive.
—lierre keith, the vegetarian myth, page 265
-
blood0pressuremonitorreviews reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
rebeoen liked this
-
interpreteruntomyself reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
rubyvroom reblogged this from eshusplayground
-
eshusplayground reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
eshusplayground liked this
-
nihilismfornegroes reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
plasticpiranhas reblogged this from lostgrrrls
-
chairfacechippendale liked this
-
nosugarjustequal reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine and added:
division of liberalism...radicalism, but I also feel as if there needs
-
youngfeminism reblogged this from lostgrrrls and added:
division of liberalism and radicalism, but...also feel as if there needs to be both...
-
felled liked this
-
gleeksfalllikedominoes liked this
-
yougurtloves liked this
-
marshmallow-martian liked this
-
mondosmusicbox liked this
-
littleplastersaint reblogged this from reinventionoftheprintingpress
-
littleplastersaint liked this
-
covergrrrl liked this
-
amaevis liked this
-
reinventionoftheprintingpress reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
carscollide liked this
-
reinventionoftheprintingpress liked this
-
twerkinfortheweekend reblogged this from lostgrrrls and added:
really beneficial to read and to know.
-
lostgrrrls reblogged this from champagnecandy and added:
I guess I fall somewhere in the middle. I think education is incredibly important, but it’s a means, not an end.
-
fgm878 liked this
-
moonghost reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
jing-lan liked this
-
pavlovianboner reblogged this from champagnecandy
-
syntheticzero reblogged this from champagnecandy and added:
If this is really...difference between liberals and radicals, then I don’t fall into...
-
planetmixtape reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine
-
ribcagerebel reblogged this from cosmopolitan-fascist
-
fappedisco reblogged this from hollvn
-
hollvn reblogged this from strugglingtobeheard and added:
I understand the harm of “feel good” consumerism and new age trends. Do yoga, drink soy milk, and save the earth. Buy...
-
ragecabinet liked this
-
notflowers liked this
-
unsubtle-knife liked this
-
herocountry reblogged this from sylviaandherfigtree
-
pretzlcoatl reblogged this from cosmopolitan-fascist
-
pretzlcoatl liked this
-
dwntotheundrgrnd reblogged this from pixiemoon42
-
sevenxletters liked this
-
blck-grrl liked this
-
strugglingtobeheard reblogged this from cosmopolitan-fascist
-
strugglingtobeheard liked this
-
shitheadoi liked this
- Show more notes